Love these two dresses for different reasons, help me pick pls

So I fell in love with Eva Lendel designs, specifically Envy (Option 1). My heart was set on Envy but I tried on Antares (Option 2) based on the store owner’s recommendation. She was right as I do love it as well (with or without should sleeve TBC). I would like to get an outside perspective as to which one I should pick and why. Open to other dress suggestions as long as they are Eva Lendel as I will be returning to the store shortly to confirm my choice.