Advice: Mid-Weight Fleece vs Down Puffy

I'm trying to choose between my mid-weight half zip fleece or my down puffy for the PCT with a late April start. Both weigh right around 10oz and I'm leaning more towards brining the fleece and leaving the puffy home for 2 reasons.. 1st, it's dual purpose as I'll hike in it but not the puffy and 2nd, because I'll be bringing a fleece sleeping bag liner so I figure if I'm cold in camp, I can wrap this around myself in addition to the mid-weight fleece which I imagine will replace the warmth of the puffy. Just looking for some advice... And I'm pretty set on keeping the liner, I know some people can hate on them but with the quilt, I like that it will help me trap warmth at night.