Vanilla Lotions

I’m trying to find a basic vanilla lotion that is vanilla and nothing else. Something that smells like melted ice cream is my goal. I have EOS Vanilla Cashmere and it's ok, but there's almost a plastic component to it that's not my favorite. I've tried all the Victoria's Secret options and I don't like them. I have everything Bath and Body Works sells (except Vanilla Bean Noel which I will be getting if I can't find another good vanilla). I don't have any particular budget in mind.