If you could experience your first playthrough on any video game again what would it be?

I remember when I was alot younger and knew a lot more on Christmas day 2007 and I did my first play through of BioShock on the 360 and I was completely blown away. I'm not sure if we'll ever get another game quite like it esthetically but I definitely with I could erase what I know about the story for a new play through lol

I'm sure this is pure nostalgia from when I was young but still.