This or that?

I had a Kicker 49l7tdf102 get stolen, along with my amps. I have more amps but am looking at the sub. Should I get another 49l7tdf102, step up to the 12" model, or put a 10" CompR 2ohm into this older ported wedge I have? I would've contemplated the CompVX but it's not gonna fit depth wise. Even if the CompR is close, I can add a ring and bring it out 3/4".

Vehicle is VW MK5 Golf