Maddy knew.

Knew as in had her suspicions, and wanted to get confirmation. There’s no way she didn’t, there’s no way she didn’t know cassie was in that hot tub and I’m thinking that’s why she didn’t want to check, any other time she would’ve definitely wanted to see. She definitely knew by how she looked at Cassie when Nate was on the stretcher, how she looked at Cassie through the rear view mirror, how she went to Kat mostly for comfort, how she started distancing herself from Cassie, and don’t even get me started on the hot tub scene.

I truly think Maddy was just in denial, but she knew. There’s no way, Cassie was way too obvious about it, both her and Nate. And then her bragging about the cute text nate sent her, yes I know their bsfs but that’s the only reason she messaged her. I truly feel so bad for Maddy, seriously.