Experienced Santas, how do you do it?

So I'm sitting here on my bedroom floor wrapping presents for my family and I look at the few gifts in front of me and realize I wrapped my husband's gift in the same paper as my son's with the same type of tag. Thankfully my son is 20 months so he won't know, but once he gets old enough to really understand "Santa," how should I do it?

When he gets older, I think I want to do only one or two "Santa" gifts and then say Santa stuffed his stocking. But for the "Santa" gifts, do you guys use different paper and tags? What are yalls tips?