Supports fail on one part but not the other

After replacing my FEP, this piece will print successfully in one spot and right next to it supports will fail. I had one success out of three parts. I’ve printed this multiple times before changing the FEP without issues. I’m kind of at a loss here. I’ve checked my exposure, filtered the resin, checked that the FEP is tight, made sure the screen is lighting where I need it to- I just can’t get this part to print successfully. It’s the randomness of it that bothers me- one fails right next to where another succeeds. Any ideas? Settings are in the second picture.