Cayman S 718 or C7 Z51

Good evening everyone, I’m currently deciding between the C7 Z51 and the Cayman S 718. Both are in roughly the same price range on the German used car market. I’m 25 years old and have previously owned a Challenger R/T and a Mustang GT. With the Porsche, I’d be taking a step away from the V8 engine for the first time. The corvette would be a nice eye catcher because you dont see them around here. I’ve test-driven both cars and fallen in love with each of them. Which one would you lean towards if you were in my position?

Wishing you all a great week!