Problem with So Juicy gloss caps?

Hey all, this is now the second So Juicy tube I have received as a replacement for a cracked cap...I would normally think I'm being too rough with them but they just stay in my bag most of the day. Has anyone experienced this? I have had to quarantine the tube to a plastic bag because it gets so messy and sticky once the cap is cracked. I really do love the formula and would hate to have to give up on it! Help!